Site logo

Difference Between Contracts and Quantity Surveying

Introduction

In the vast world of construction and infrastructure development, two terms frequently appear—Contracts and Quantity Surveying. At first time, they may seem interconnected, and indeed, they often work side by side in the execution of projects. However, they are not the same.

  • Contracts refer to the legal agreements that define the rights, obligations, and responsibilities of all parties involved in a  project.
  • Quantity Surveying (QS) is a professional discipline that deals with estimating, managing, and controlling the financial and cost aspects of construction.

In simple terms:

  • Contracts = The rules of the game
  • Quantity Surveying = The financial management of the game

This article explains the main differences between Contracts and Quantity Surveying, their roles, responsibilities, significance, career paths, and future outlooks.

What Are Contracts in Construction?

Contracts are legally binding agreements between two or more parties in a construction project. They define the scope of work, payment terms, timelines, responsibilities, dispute mechanisms, and risk allocations.

Key Elements of Construction Contracts:

  1. Parties Involved – Client, contractor, subcontractors, suppliers.
  2. Scope of Work – What needs to be built, the quality, and specifications.
  3. Payment Terms – How and when payments will be made.
  4. Timeframe – Project start date, completion date, and milestones.
  5. Risk Allocation – Who bears the cost of delays, material price fluctuations, etc.
  6. Dispute Resolution – Mechanisms for arbitration, mediation, or litigation.

Without a contract, a project risks disputes, financial losses, and legal complications.

What is Quantity Surveying?

Quantity Surveying is a professional service within the construction industry that manages the financial, cost, and contractual aspects of projects. The Quantity Surveyor ensures that construction projects are financially viable, cost-efficient, and completed within budget.

Key Responsibilities of a Quantity Surveyor:

  • Preparing cost estimates and budgets.
  • Preparing Bills of Quantities (BOQ).
  • Advising on procurement methods.
  • Cost control during construction.
  • Certifying payments to contractors.
  • Managing variations and changes in scope.
  • Preparing final accounts after completion.

A QS does not just measure quantities; they are cost consultants and contract administrators.

Key Differences Between Contracts and Quantity Surveying

Let us break down the main differences clearly:

  1. Definition
  • Contracts: Legal agreements that define responsibilities, rights, and obligations.
  • Quantity Surveying: Professional service that manages costs and financial aspects.
  1. Nature of Work
  • Contracts: Concerned with legal and binding frameworks.
  • Quantity Surveying: Concerned with financial and cost management.
  1. Primary Focus
  • Contracts: Rights, obligations, risk allocation, dispute resolution.
  • QS: Estimation, budgeting, cost control, and payment certification.
  1. Who Manages Them?
  • Contracts: Lawyers, contract administrators, or contract managers.
  • QS: Quantity Surveyors, cost consultants, or commercial managers.
  1. Tools Used
  • Contracts: Legal documents, standard forms (e.g., FIDIC, JCT, NEC).
  • QS: Estimation software, Excel, BIM-integrated cost tools.
  1. Risk Involvement
  • Contracts: Allocates and defines who bears risk.
  • QS: Identifies, measures, and mitigates financial risks.
  1. Stage of Involvement
  • Contracts: Begin at the negotiation stage and remain valid until project completion.
  • QS: Involved from pre-construction (estimation) until post-construction (final accounts).

How Contracts and Quantity Surveying Work Together

Though different, Contracts and QS are closely linked. For instance:

  • A contract may specify payment terms, but the QS certifies those payments.
  • A contract defines how variations will be handled, and the QS measures and prices them.
  • In disputes, contracts provide the legal framework, while the QS provides cost data and evidence.

In short: Contracts provide the law, Quantity Surveying provides the numbers.

Educational Pathways

For Contracts (Contract Management Professionals):

  • Degrees in Law, Construction Management, or Business Administration.
  • Certifications in Contract Law, Arbitration, or Project Management.
  • Knowledge of FIDIC, JCT, NEC, and local contract forms.

For Quantity Surveyors:

  • Degree in Quantity Surveying, Civil Engineering, or Construction Economics.
  • Professional membership in RICS (UK), AIQS (Australia), or IIQS (India).
  • Training in cost estimation, procurement, and contract administration.

Skills Required

Contract Professionals:

  • Strong legal knowledge.
  • Negotiation and drafting skills.
  • Risk analysis.
  • Dispute resolution expertise.

Quantity Surveyors:

  • Strong mathematical and analytical ability.
  • Budgeting and cost estimation.
  • Knowledge of construction methods.
  • Contract administration.

Career Opportunities

Contracts (Contract Management):

  • Contract Manager
  • Legal Consultant
  • Claims Consultant
  • Contract Administrator

Quantity Surveying:

  • Quantity Surveyor
  • Cost Consultant
  • Commercial Manager
  • Project Cost Manager

Salary Structure

  • Contract Professionals: Salaries depend on expertise in contract law and international standards. Highly paid in oil, gas, and mega projects.
  • Quantity Surveyors: Salaries depend on cost management expertise. High demand in Middle East, UK, and Asia-Pacific.

Similarities Between Contracts and Quantity Surveying

Despite differences, both:

  • Aim to reduce risks in projects.
  • Ensure fairness between parties.
  • Are critical for smooth project execution.
  • Work together during disputes and claims.

Challenges in Both Fields

  • Contracts: Interpreting complex clauses, handling disputes, adapting to changing laws.
  • QS: Managing cost escalations, inaccurate estimations, rapid market changes.

Conclusion

The difference between Contracts and Quantity Surveying lies in their focus and function within the construction industry. Contracts provide the legal framework that governs projects, while Quantity Surveying ensures financial discipline and cost efficiency.

Both are essential for successful project delivery. Contracts without QS can lead to financial mismanagement, while QS without contracts can lead to legal disputes. Together, they form the backbone of project success, ensuring that construction is legally sound, financially viable, and efficiently executed.

For students, professionals, or businesses in construction, understanding this difference is crucial for making informed decisions and building a successful career.

Scroll to Top